Compare Merrell vs. Columbia Hiking Boots: Which One Outweighs The Other?

Both Merrell vs. Columbia hiking boots is great suggestions for hikers. If you are considering choosing between the two, read this article first to know the difference!

Top Rated Best Merrell Hiking Boots for Good Budget

Top Rated Best Columbia Hiking Boots for Good Budget

Merrell vs. Columbia Hiking Boots: Comparison Table

Before going any deeper, let’s check this detailed Merrell and Columbia Hiking Boots comparison table. It will give you an overview of how they differ.

Merrell Hiking Boots

Columbia Hiking Boots


Good Midsole Support

Decent Outsole

Excellent Fitness and Support


  • Excellent ventilation, keeping you feeling comfy and airy.
  • Ideal for people who prefer practicality and safety more than anything else

Head-To-Head Comparison: Merrell vs. Columbia Hiking Boots

Columbia vs. Merrell Hiking Boots has actually come with unique pros and cons that serve a specific purpose. Let me walk you through the core differences between these two categories.

Merrell Hiking Boots

If you’re a fan of outdoor activities, chances are you’ve heard of Merrell, a revolutionary footwear brand loved by a lot of hikers.

In more than ten years of effort, this brand has created unique designs for approximately 20 million people worldwide and helped them achieve their goals.

Their technologically advanced and ultra-lightweight shoes let you tackle any trail. Plus, they increase your confidence when doing any outdoor activity.

In addition, the products of this brand are specially made for go-getter personalities who only see the goal and victory ahead of them.

Columbia Hiking Boots

Columbia is one of the famous brands when it comes to shoes and boots.

The brand started in 1937 with the mission to solve all the problems people might have with their feet.

Since then, the brand has continuously launched excellent footwear collections using the signature Omni-Grip feature. It offers comfort that you won’t get from other brands.

#1. Midsole Support

Boots’ cushioning in the midsole plays an essential role in providing perfect comfort and support.

If you choose stable hiking boots, you’ll have more fun enjoying your outdoor activities than focusing on the severe pain in your foot. It is always wise to choose midsoles made from polyurethane and EVA.

The good news is that both Merrell and Columbia offer many models with well-padded midsoles, which promise you a comfortable experience for hours outdoors. So there is no winner in this round.

The winner: Draw.

#2. Outsoles

Rubber is one of the ideal options for the outsoles of hiking boots and shoes. Some mountaineering boots feature carbon outsoles, which can improve durability.

But their increased hardness might make your shoes feel stiff a bit during hiking.

So we recommend opting for models that feature rubber outsoles with lug patterns, which can increase traction. Thanks to that, you move around the wet mud quickly and easily.

Again, both Merrell and Columbia are doing a great job with the outsoles of their shoes and boots. Therefore, this category ends in a tie.

The winner: Draw.

#4. Price

Price is one of the factors that you must consider when purchasing anything.

The key is to buy the best model within your budget to avoid breaking the bank.

Therefore, it is not surprising that both Merrell and Columbia offer models at various price points.

These brands aim to make it easy for anyone to find something that fits their budget and needs.

The winner: Draw.

#5. Stiness And Support

These hiking boots are packed with decent, durable support to prevent bites from insects or snakes. So they will keep you safe throughout your journey.

Besides, one of the aspects that make these boots ideal for hiking is their excellent arch and ankle support. As a result, they allow you to hike for miles on rough terrain easily and comfortably.

The winner: Draw.

#6. Comfort

The all-weather comfort and versatility of boots will allow you to easily traverse dust, rocky, and snow surfaces you may encounter during your hiking journey.

Fortunately, you can rest assured with Columbia and Merrell boots to get the energized feel, even if you go hiking for many hours.

Merrell vs. Columbia Hiking Boots: Which One Is Better?

One of the significant differences between Merrell and Columbia hiking boots is signature traction and how they focus on aesthetics. The other thing is using unique technology to deal with fears you have never experienced.

In addition, the difference also lies in the fact that Merrell models are excellent in ventilation, keeping your feeling comfy and airy, while Columbia ones are ideal for people who prefer practicality and safety more than anything else.

Although there is a slight difference between the two, if you look at the bigger image, you’ll see that these boots are great for hiking as they serve well the primary purpose of a pair of hiking boots: durable and waterproof.

In addition to providing the necessary protection for your feet on long hikes, these boots are also aesthetically pleasing, making the wearer look fashionable and stylish.


The answers and information below will help you gain more insights into the traits and qualities of Merrell and Columbia Hiking Boots.

Does Columbia make a good hiking boot?

Yes. Columbia hiking boots are a fantastic option whether you are searching for hiking boots, trail running shoes, comfortable outdoor shoes, or snow boots.

Are Merrells good quality?

Its products may be good enough for:

  • Hikers with wide feet.
  • Budget-oriented hikers.
  • Casual hikers who prefer well-maintained trails.

But Merrell shoes may not be ideal if you favor excellent overall quality, solid ankle support, and reliable waterproofing.

Are Columbia hiking boots good for cold weather?

Columbia hiking boots can be perfect for people looking for comfortable winter boots to help them embrace winter’s unpredictable weather.

Is Merrells good for walking?

Merrell has developed a new iteration of the classic walking shoes, designed for those who favor feeling agile and light-footed on their trail.

They are hybrid-type trainers, one with the comfort of running shoes or sneakers but the protection of walking shoes.

How Should Columbia hiking boots fit?

Regarding hiking boots, it is wise to order up a half-size. They should not be too loose anywhere in boots except for your toes.

If your foot is sliding around inside your boots even when they are tied tight, that is not a good fit (also a cause of skinned feet and blisters).

To choose a suitable pair of boots, there is nothing better than trying them on in person. Try on a boost you like and walk around the store a few rounds to ensure it’s right for you.

Are Merrell hiking shoes comfortable?

Merrell hiking shoes are extremely comfortable right out of the box, offering sufficient traction and support for non-technical trails. They can even do the trick on the shorter backpacking trip.

How warm are Columbia boots?

Merrell models are built on four pillars: Durability, design, comfort, and versatility. That is why these boots are all made with an anatomical footbed with arch support and a built-in heel counter.

Are Merrell Shoes Made in China?

Merrell shoes and boots are made both in the US and in Asian countries like Vietnam.

How Many Miles Will Merrell Shoes Last?

In general, most hiking shoes should last about 350 to 500 miles.

What are the Best Columbia Hiking Boots?

Here are the 6 best Columbia hiking boots:

1. Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II Waterproof

>>> Today’s Best Deal: Check Latest Price on Amazon


  • Comfortable all-day wear
  • Short break-in time
  • Lightweight
  • Grips well
  • Affordable


  • Not durable
  • Ineffective waterproofing
  • Insufficient ankle support

2. Columbia Fairbanks Omni-Heat Boot

>>> Today’s Best Deal: Check Latest Price on Amazon


  • Stylish design
  • Reasonably priced
  • Zero break-in period
  • Quality construction
  • Amazingly comfortable
  • Extremely lightweight
  • Offer plenty of protection


  • Too narrow
  • Lack of waterproofing
  • The strong chemical smell didn’t go away

3. Columbia Fairbanks Rover

>>> Today’s Best Deal: Check Latest Price on Amazon


  • Waterproof
  • Value for money
  • Appealing design
  • Day-one comfort
  • Superb insulation
  • Solid construction
  • Keeps moisture out
  • Barely-there lightness
  • Great for cold conditions


  • Narrow fit
  • Low tongue gusset

4. Columbia Trailstorm Mid Waterproof

>>> Today’s Best Deal: Check Latest Price on Amazon


  • Reliable collar
  • Ankle support
  • Impermeable
  • Grippy boot
  • Plush right away
  • Impressively light
  • Attractive design
  • Keeps the feet dry
  • No break-in period


  • Lacks heel support
  • Not enough breathability

5. Columbia Peakfreak X2 Mid Outdry

>>> Today’s Best Deal: Check Latest Price on Amazon


  • Supportive
  • Comfortable
  • Grippy outsole
  • Featherweight
  • Head-turning design
  • Impressively watertight
  • Keeps the tootsies cozy
  • Comfy straight from the box


  • Slick laces
  • Challenging access

6. Columbia Gunnison II Omni-Heat

>>> Today’s Best Deal: Check Latest Price on Amazon


  • Waterproof
  • Spot-on fit
  • Grippy outsole
  • High-quality kicks
  • Excellent insulation
  • Keeps moisture out
  • Sticks on snowy paths
  • Great boot for winter
  • Incredible level of comfort


  • Frail toe guard

Leave a Comment